Welcome to the ODAC Newsletter, a weekly roundup from the Oil Depletion Analysis Centre, the UK registered charity dedicated to raising awareness of peak oil.
In a busy week for energy policy, UK energy watchdog Ofgem finally acknowledged what has been obvious for years: that liberalized markets cannot deliver energy security in the era of carbon reduction and resource depletion. Its report suggested the market would not deliver the £200 billion needed for energy infrastructure over the next decade without far more government intervention, and suggested a range of radical measures – at least in terms of the mainstream British energy debate. Some, such as a minimum carbon price, have been championed by ODAC for some time.
One danger identified by Ofgem is Britain’s growing dependency on imported natural gas, as North Sea production declines. BP boss Tony Hayward gave a number of ‘exclusive’ interviews this week in which he talked of ‘misplaced paranoia’ over gas supplies, but ODAC trustee David Strahan argues that the Ofgem report contains some valid recommendations. With the general election looming, we may soon enjoy the irony of a Conservative administration re-regulating the industry it deregulated with such gusto in the 1980’s.
Meanwhile Labour’s Climate and Energy Secretary Ed Miliband announced the long awaited incentives for micro-energy generation. The feed-in tariffs (FITs), which guarantee returns of 5-8% even if householders consume the energy generated themselves, were generally welcomed by the industry. But as expected the subsidies were less generous than those of Germany where FITs have proved such a success, suggesting the government is still trying to get its energy policy on the cheap. It is also depressing that it has taken the government so long to reach this point. The European countries that have far more renewable capacity than Britain have almost all used FITs for years.
President Obama announced his draft budget this week in which he proposed, for the second time, ending subsidies on oil & gas as they are “unaffordable”. The industry condemned the move citing that it would slow down investment in tight gas, and the measure will no doubt face a tough hearing. Between the State of the Union speech, the budget and a further statement on energy on Wednesday this week, Obama has determined to increase investment in carbon capture and storage, nuclear power and next generation biofuels, and make hard decisions on off-shore oil and gas drilling. Whether such a policy will reduce US vulnerability to peak oil is highly questionable.
Financial results for 2009 announced by the big energy companies this week held few surprises. Slumping demand and lower oil and gas prices led to lower profits. But lower is a relative term, since 2008 was a record year.
Oil
Terry Macalister, The Guardian, 04 Feb 2010
Shell is to sell off 15% of its refinery capacity in Europe and the Americas after reporting a 75% collapse in final-quarter profits and a slump in annual results.
Peter Voser, the chief executive, said four previous years of increased profits had allowed the company to "to eat too much and get fat"...
Back to top
Robin Pagnamenta, Energy Editor, The Times, 03 Feb 2010
BP blamed a $2.6 billion (£1.6 billion) loss in its United States refining division yesterday as it revealed its weakest annual profits in six years.
Tony Hayward, the chief executive, also issued a gloomy assessment of the prospects for recovery, warning that it would take “three to four years” for activity to return to the levels seen three years ago...
Back to top
BBC Online, 03 Feb 2010
Opec has told the BBC World Service that compliance with production targets fell to 50-56% last month compared to 80% a year ago.
Secretary General Abdalla Salem El-Badri told the BBC's Business Daily programme it is "worrying" and could lead to oversupply and price falls...
Back to top
Reuters, 02 Feb 2010
Nigeria plans to sell oilfield assets this year containing as much as 2 billion barrels of reserves either relinquished by Western firms or unsold in three previous bidding rounds, the Financial Times reported Tuesday.
A bidding round for the assets, which could also include oil blocks not previously offered, may attract Asian groups and local companies, the newspaper said quoting Emmanuel Egbogah, special adviser to the president on petroleum matters...
Back to top
North America
Melinda Burns, Miller McCune, 04 Feb 2010
Nearly every U.S. president, Republican or Democrat, since Richard Nixon has called on the United States to kick its addiction to foreign oil.
“In the last third of this century,” Nixon said in 1973, “our independence will depend on maintaining and achieving self-sufficiency in energy.”..
Back to top
John M. Broder, New York Times, 03 Feb 2010
President Obama moved on Wednesday to bolster the nation’s production of corn-based ethanol and other alternative liquid fuels and ordered the rapid development of technology to capture carbon dioxide emissions from the burning of coal.
The president is trying to expand the portfolio of American energy sources to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases, a factor in global warming, and spur advances in alternative technologies. Last week he expressed support in his State of the Union address for increased generation of nuclear power and offshore drilling for oil and gas...
Back to top
Des Moines Register, 03 Feb 2010
The nation won't meet its biofuels goals unless the government accelerates the development of biofuel crops and products, the White House says.
In a report being released today, an administration task force said the government needs, among other things, to set targets for commercializing new types of fuel crops, such as switchgrass.
The government also needs to work regionally to develop fuels and feedstocks that make sense in each part of the nation, the report said...
Back to top
Ayesha Rascoe and Joshua Schneyer, Reuters, 01 Feb 2010
The Obama administration on Monday asked Congress for a second time to end some $36.5 billion in subsidies for oil and gas companies, saying it would help fight global warming.
In its proposed budget for the government's 2011 spending year that starts October 1, the administration said eliminating the subsidies would "foster the clean energy economy of the future and reduce our reliance on fossil fuels that contribute to climate change."...
Back to top
Nuclear
James Bone in New York and Catherine Philp, Diplomatic Correspondent, The Times, 04 Feb 2010
President Ahmadinejad demonstrated yesterday that he has become a master of playing cat and mouse with the West — and this time the mouse was real.
Once again, the Iranian leader offered a last-minute concession to head off the West’s drive for new sanctions against the Islamic republic. At the same time, Iran thumbed its nose at UN restrictions on its ballistic missiles programme by sending a rocket into space carrying a mouse, two turtles and some worms...
Back to top
Danny Fortson, The Times, 31 Jan 2010
It’s an odd place for a group of Frenchmen to pitch a tent city. Bakouma is one of the deepest, darkest corners of African jungle. From Bangui, the capital of the land-locked Central African Republic, it takes days to navigate the 800km of dirt track to this patch of virgin forest in the middle of the continent. Usually they go by light aircraft to a nearby landing strip.
Most of the 160 or so jungle dwellers are scientists but they are not there to count butterflies. They are drawing up plans for a uranium mine. Areva, France’s state-owned nuclear giant, is behind the project. It hopes to begin clearing forest next year after the government approves its plan...
Back to top
Renewables
EurActiv, 04 Feb 2010
EU member states this week (2 February) agreed how to allocate billions worth of EU money from the bloc's emissions trading scheme (EU ETS) to support renewable energies and emerging technology to capture carbon dioxide and store it underground.
After a year of negotiations to fine-tune the details, national experts approved a proposal on how to use 300 million emission allowances from the scheme's 'new entrants reserve' to finance projects in renewables and CCS (Carbon Capture and Storage; see EurActiv LinksDossier)...
Back to top
Tom Young, Business Green, 04 Feb 2010
China overtook the USA for volumes of new installations and manufacturing of wind turbines for the first time in 2009, according to a report by the Global Wind Energy Council (GWEC).
The world’s wind power capacity grew by 37.5GW to 157.9GW during the year, with a third (13GW) of these additions made in China, which doubled its capacity in the period...
Back to top
Keith Bradsher, New York Times, 30 Jan 2010
China vaulted past competitors in Denmark, Germany, Spain and the United States last year to become the world’s largest maker of wind turbines, and is poised to expand even further this year.
China has also leapfrogged the West in the last two years to emerge as the world’s largest manufacturer of solar panels. And the country is pushing equally hard to build nuclear reactors and the most efficient types of coal power plants...
Back to top
Biofuels
EurActiv, 03 Feb 2010
The EU's current indecision on environmental criteria for biomass could discredit the whole industry, which lives off its climate-friendly image, Eric Johnson, managing director of Atlantic Consulting, told EurActiv in an interview.
"The problem with not having criteria is very large. It's very easy for people to source non-sustainable biomass, which basically damages the environment and potentially damages human health," said Johnson, who is also editor of the scholarly journal Environmental Impact Assessment Review...
Back to top
Rowena Mason, Telegraph, 02 Feb 2010
Royal Dutch Shell has moved to take shared control of the world's largest sugar processor in the hope of promoting ethanol as a green fuel for US and European markets.
Cosan will provide $5bn of its assets, including all its production facilities and an ethanol-trading unit, while Shell will contribute $2bn in cash, 2,740 service stations, and stakes in two green technology businesses. The 50-50 joint venture will assume Cosan's $2.5bn of debt...
Back to top
The New Scientist, 28 Jan 2010
ALGAE have been touted as a solution to environmental worries over biofuels, but they may be a long way from providing a truly green option.
Unlike maize, soya beans and oilseed rape (canola), algal farms don't take up valuable farmland, so algae-based biofuels don't threaten food supplies. However, Andres Clarens at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville has modelled the environmental impacts of algal farms and concludes that they require six times as much energy as growing land plants - and emit significantly more greenhouse gases (Environmental Science and Technology, DOI: 10.1021/es902838n)....
Back to top
UK
Ed Crooks and Fiona Harvey, Financial Times, 04 Feb 2010
Radical reforms of Britain's energy market are likely after the election, the government and opposition both signalled yesterday, as regulator Ofgem gave warning of threats to electricity and gas supplies before the end of the decade.
An Ofgem report said there was a "window of opportunity" until about 2012-13 to put a new market framework in place to deliver up to £200bn of investment needed to secure energy supplies and cut carbon emissions...
View report
Back to top
David Strahan, Telegraph, 04 Feb 2010
Yesterday's Ofgem report was a wake-up call. The Government must act now to improve Britain's rapidly deteriorating energy security, warns David Strahan.
Bad news for energy consumers continues to come thick and fast. Bills have more than doubled in the past six years, and could rise a further 25 per cent in the next decade according to a wide-ranging report published yesterday by Ofgem. But even more worrying was the watchdog's analysis of Britain's energy security – or lack of it. Without decisive action, warns Ofgem, there could soon be times when energy is not just expensive but unavailable at any price...
Back to top
Terry Macalister and Deborah Hargreaves, The Guardian, 04 Feb 2010
Britain's offshore wind revolution, launched with great fanfare by Gordon Brown last month, may struggle to get halfway to its ambitious goals and should be scaled down in favour of a new dash for gas to keep the lights on over the next 10 years, BP warned last night.
Tony Hayward, chief executive of the UK's largest oil company, said that British government ministers risked being seduced by "headline-grabbing options" such as offshore wind and clean coal in a bid to bolster energy security and meet climate-change goals. BP makes billions of pounds a year from oil and gas, but is also investing in onshore wind farms in America...
Back to top
Louise Gray, Environment Correspondent, The Daily Telegraph, 02 Feb 2010
Under the deal, which will start from April this year, households will be paid for electricity fed into the grid from renewable technologies such as solar, wind or energy from waste.
The most attractive rate of return will be on solar panels, which for an average sized three bedroom home could earn households £25,000 over 25 years...
Back to top
Hayley Millar, BBC Online, 02 Feb 2010
Three Scottish companies have won a multi-million pound funding boost to help prove the commercial viability of their marine power devices.
The money from the Department of Energy and Climate change, DECC, is awarded by The Carbon Trust...
Back to top
Climate
BBC Online, 31 Jan 2010
Governments around the world have reaffirmed their plans to cut greenhouse gas emissions in support of last month's Copenhagen climate summit.
Nations signing up to the summit accord were urged to outline pledges by Sunday. States producing at least two-thirds of emissions have done so...
Back to top
Louise Gray, The Daily Telegraph, 04 Feb 2010
Lord Smith of Finsbury, the Chairman of the Environment Agency, said the climate is changing and the UK is in danger of suffering more extreme weather events like the recent floods in Cumbria.
But he said "sloppy and irresponsible" emails sent by scientists from the University of East Anglia in a scandal known as "climategate" was being used by sceptics to cast doubt on the whole argument.
He also said a mistaken claim by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) that the Himalayas will melt by 2035, known as "glaciergate", was being used by critics to suggest that the UN body is not to be trusted...
Back to top