Some investors may be under the impression the oil crisis is over. After all, the price of crude has fallen to $37 (U.S.) a barrel from $42 a couple of weeks ago, thanks to promises from Saudi Arabia that it will boost production in order to keep up with demand. Even the news that terrorist groups blew up a key pipeline in Iraq failed to push crude prices up to any great extent Wednesday. But some oil industry experts feel the market has traded irrational fear for irrational complacency. With the Saudis now pumping more oil, they say, there is very little spare capacity should supply from Iraq be disrupted for more than a few weeks.
According to news reports, saboteurs blew up two pipelines north of the town of Faw on Wednesday — pipelines that had already been the target of attacks on Tuesday. A senior security officer with Iraq's Northern Oil Co. was also killed in an ambush. The latest blasts crippled the pipelines, an Iraqi spokesman said, and as a result the movement of oil to the terminal in the southern Gulf port of Basra "has completely stopped." Exports through the country's northern pipeline to Turkey stopped last month after a similar attack. Meanwhile, the U.S. Energy Department said crude stockpiles rose by 800,000 barrels for the latest week — compared with estimates of 1.5 million.
The strategy at OPEC in the wake of the Iraq attacks seems to be a typical one: Say one thing and do another. The global oil cartel said Monday that a supply disruption was no problem, and that Saudi Arabia — the only OPEC member with spare production capacity — would be more than able to make up for any drop in Iraqi exports. A Saudi promise to boost its output by more than 10 per cent to 9.1 million barrels a day was what originally helped push oil back to the $37 range from $42. At the same time, however, OPEC president Purnomo Ysgiantoro said Wednesday that he was writing a letter to non-OPEC producers such as Russia asking them to raise production.
The point is not just that Russia, Angola and Mexico are in no position to produce much more oil — a senior Russian oil minister, for example, said the country didn't "have a tap that we can just turn on and off; we are producing exactly as much as we can." The important point is this: Why is OPEC busy asking Russia and other non-cartel producers to boost their production if Saudi Arabia has everything under control? In the not-too-distant past, asking Russia to produce more crude would have been the last thing on earth the Saudis wanted to do, because it would have meant giving Russia a greater share of the global oil market.
Now, however, OPEC needs all the help it can get if crude prices aren't going to spike again. The Saudis are in the process of boosting their output to 9.1 million barrels a day, and according to official estimates they could come up with another 1.4 million barrels if necessary without having to do a lot of work expanding their existing oil fields. But even that wouldn't make up for the loss of 1.8 million barrels a day from Iraq. Such a disruption may not be a huge strain on the market in the short term, but it could become one before long.
Energy Intelligence analyst Axel Busch told CNN on Wednesday that the amount of oil being blocked in Iraq almost matches available spare capacity in OPEC, and that "it wouldn't take a lot to push up against the buffers as there's not much slack. If there's not enough to go around, then the sky's the limit." Leo Drollas, chief economist at the Center for Global Energy Studies in London, told Associated Press he was surprised at the market's lack of reaction. "Spare capacity in the world is only 2.2 million barrels, which is only 2.7 per cent of expected third-quarter world demand," he said.
Even some within OPEC are concerned about the supply issue. A source told Dow Jones that "there is very little leverage for extra barrels despite what some (within OPEC) are saying." But the cartel continues to maintain that it will have no difficulty in keeping up with demand. "In a temporary crisis like this, we'll be there to take care of the problem," OPEC spokesman Omar Farouk Ibrahim told Bloomberg. Those reassurances seem to be enough to placate traders — at least for now, that is. "We're all waiting for the Saudi barrels to arrive, which allows us to shrug off news we are getting from Iraq," said Phil Flynn, a senior energy trader for Alaron Trading Corp. in Chicago.
With OPEC production reaching its limits and other producers not able to fill the void, however, that complacency could face a serious test if Iraq's oil exports are put on hold for much longer than a week or two. At the very least, the supply-demand equation for crude is likely to remain extremely tight, despite all the soothing noises that are coming out of OPEC.
E-mail Mathew Ingram at firstname.lastname@example.org
For past columns and a brief biography, click here
Look for exclusive commentary by Mathew Ingram at GlobeInvestorGold